I’ve applied to test knit on several occasions but have never been ‘chosen’. On several occasions I’ve been asked for my Instagram handle; I don’t post much there so wonder if that is a deciding factor for the knit designer - they are missing out on 65 years of knitting experience but hi hum do I care - strangely, yes!! Is it like not being chosen for games!
I do often send designers corrections for their patterns after publication.
I've done several test knits over the last 5 or so years, mostly for one designer with a few others tossed in. One I actually used the yarn that was recommended, only because it was a new yarn from one of my favorite dyers and I wanted to try it out. All the rest had a suggested yarn but testers were free to use stash if they chose to. For every test knit that I've done the only payment I received was a copy of the tested pattern and sometimes another pattern, either from the designer's collection or a choice of patterns from Ravelry. I pick and choose test knits based on my schedule and if I can fit in the time needed.
I have done 3 testknits, all small things. in 2 of 3 cases, I found a small mistake, so it feels my 'job' was usefull. also in 2 of 3 cases I was not 100% happy with the result, and I would not have choosen the pattern if I had all the information from the very beginning. that is not a drama, that is why I only commit to small knits/crochet. I have learned a few things while doing those testknits, that is also a positive part of the experience. so, once a year, a one-skein-testknit: I like it.
I have similar feelings and reasons for being a test knitter. I've done a few over the past 3 years. One thing I find surprising is the wait to see the final published pattern. In one case, a sweater I knitted way back in Fall of 2022, just came out for sale this spring. Another test I did in '22, I've never seen it released. So, it can be a long wait for the share, if it's supposed to be secret!
I thought, before volunteering as a tester, I would get compensation. But, overall, I certainly do not regret my testing experiences. I enjoyed all the items I made: both creating them and wearing.
It's a fun way to challenge yourself with new skills too. So, there are rewards. Just not as tangible as monetary compensation.
I've never been interested in test knitting, but I see nothing wrong with it as long as the designer is very clear about the expectations for the testers and what they will and won't be getting in exchange for test knitting. Then the potential testers can make an informed decision about whether or not the test knit is right for them.
Hello! I test knit in Nov, just before the holiday season kicked off. Luckily it was an accessory and not a sweater. The designer was strict, I felt pressure. The decreases were not working out so I sent email, only to find out there was an update to the pattern not shared. In the end, I finished early and was happy with the object. Since then I have no desire to test knit. These days with the cost of yarn (topic for another day) I really try to mindful of new projects. I appreciate the reviews and pictures on Ravelry. Love reading all the feedback in this forum.
I love this. I test knit. A lot actually (I say I won’t take on another and BAM, a new design and up goes my hand). I test for two designers almost exclusively now. I love their designs and would almost always happily knit whatever they design. So being the first on the block to have knit ‘it’ is kind of fun! And you put into words what I hadn’t been able to do up until now - I like supporting the creative process of these talented women (my small contribution to the arts, maybe?). Both support a community feeling during the test and give plenty of time to complete the project. And most importantly are there immediately if the testers run into issues. And I think the last is almost as important as giving enough time. I was in one test in which the designer disappeared for 3 weeks when the design had major flaws. So infuriating!
My experience is similar to yours. I now also test almost exclusively for two designers because they are both always available for advice, are so easy-going, and have managed to collect a fun and supportive pool of test knitters, so the process almost feels like a mystery knit-along. I don't have any friends who are knitters or a wool shop in my town, so this is one way for me to enjoy being part of a knitting community.
I fully agree with all your comments re test knits! I’ve done 3 test knits 2 for designers that I like their previous work and 1 for a yarn friend so had a good idea what to expect! Gave me a chance to try new skills and hopefully help the wider knitting community.
I love testing but I test crochet ...my knitting isn't really up to scratch!! but I love how I can connect with the designers. Sometimes it is stressful but I also love to see the new creations and to help them with their new projects. Sometimes I am "paid" in yarn which is always lovely!
I’ve applied to test knit on several occasions but have never been ‘chosen’. On several occasions I’ve been asked for my Instagram handle; I don’t post much there so wonder if that is a deciding factor for the knit designer - they are missing out on 65 years of knitting experience but hi hum do I care - strangely, yes!! Is it like not being chosen for games!
I do often send designers corrections for their patterns after publication.
I've done several test knits over the last 5 or so years, mostly for one designer with a few others tossed in. One I actually used the yarn that was recommended, only because it was a new yarn from one of my favorite dyers and I wanted to try it out. All the rest had a suggested yarn but testers were free to use stash if they chose to. For every test knit that I've done the only payment I received was a copy of the tested pattern and sometimes another pattern, either from the designer's collection or a choice of patterns from Ravelry. I pick and choose test knits based on my schedule and if I can fit in the time needed.
I have done 3 testknits, all small things. in 2 of 3 cases, I found a small mistake, so it feels my 'job' was usefull. also in 2 of 3 cases I was not 100% happy with the result, and I would not have choosen the pattern if I had all the information from the very beginning. that is not a drama, that is why I only commit to small knits/crochet. I have learned a few things while doing those testknits, that is also a positive part of the experience. so, once a year, a one-skein-testknit: I like it.
One Skein projects are great! But I agree too about it almost being a preview and you get to sample the project before it goes on release.
I have similar feelings and reasons for being a test knitter. I've done a few over the past 3 years. One thing I find surprising is the wait to see the final published pattern. In one case, a sweater I knitted way back in Fall of 2022, just came out for sale this spring. Another test I did in '22, I've never seen it released. So, it can be a long wait for the share, if it's supposed to be secret!
I thought, before volunteering as a tester, I would get compensation. But, overall, I certainly do not regret my testing experiences. I enjoyed all the items I made: both creating them and wearing.
It's a fun way to challenge yourself with new skills too. So, there are rewards. Just not as tangible as monetary compensation.
I've never been interested in test knitting, but I see nothing wrong with it as long as the designer is very clear about the expectations for the testers and what they will and won't be getting in exchange for test knitting. Then the potential testers can make an informed decision about whether or not the test knit is right for them.
Hello! I test knit in Nov, just before the holiday season kicked off. Luckily it was an accessory and not a sweater. The designer was strict, I felt pressure. The decreases were not working out so I sent email, only to find out there was an update to the pattern not shared. In the end, I finished early and was happy with the object. Since then I have no desire to test knit. These days with the cost of yarn (topic for another day) I really try to mindful of new projects. I appreciate the reviews and pictures on Ravelry. Love reading all the feedback in this forum.
I love this. I test knit. A lot actually (I say I won’t take on another and BAM, a new design and up goes my hand). I test for two designers almost exclusively now. I love their designs and would almost always happily knit whatever they design. So being the first on the block to have knit ‘it’ is kind of fun! And you put into words what I hadn’t been able to do up until now - I like supporting the creative process of these talented women (my small contribution to the arts, maybe?). Both support a community feeling during the test and give plenty of time to complete the project. And most importantly are there immediately if the testers run into issues. And I think the last is almost as important as giving enough time. I was in one test in which the designer disappeared for 3 weeks when the design had major flaws. So infuriating!
My experience is similar to yours. I now also test almost exclusively for two designers because they are both always available for advice, are so easy-going, and have managed to collect a fun and supportive pool of test knitters, so the process almost feels like a mystery knit-along. I don't have any friends who are knitters or a wool shop in my town, so this is one way for me to enjoy being part of a knitting community.
I fully agree with all your comments re test knits! I’ve done 3 test knits 2 for designers that I like their previous work and 1 for a yarn friend so had a good idea what to expect! Gave me a chance to try new skills and hopefully help the wider knitting community.
I’ve test knit for lots of designers. I’m a number and symmetry person so I love helping to flesh out a new pattern and confirm stitch counts.
I take the projects seriously and always knit to pattern (that’s the assignment!)
I love to knit and it supports my mental health. It’s a win/win.
I have always wanted to test knit but I don’t even really know how to get my name out there for that.
I love testing but I test crochet ...my knitting isn't really up to scratch!! but I love how I can connect with the designers. Sometimes it is stressful but I also love to see the new creations and to help them with their new projects. Sometimes I am "paid" in yarn which is always lovely!